The post looks sophisticated. It talks about Edwards, the state of the inner man, and “bounded freedom.” It even accuses the doctrine of God’s sovereignty of a category error. But the whole thing is itself a category error—the exact kind of logical violation Vincent Cheung first brought to our attention many years ago. It affirms the major premise that God absolutely and completely controls all things, then tries to smuggle in a little leftover independence for man when he picks among infinite good options. That’s not a refinement. That’s a contradiction wearing a tuxedo and pretending the dualism isn’t still hanging out the back.
In my Systematic Theology I put it this way: All things are things absolutely and completely controlled by God. That is the biblical major premise. Scripture produces it. Ephesians 1:11 says God works all things according to the counsel of His will. Proverbs 21:1 says the king’s heart is in the hand of the Lord; He turns it wherever He wants. Philippians 2:13 says God works in you both to will and to do. Romans 9 gives the Potter/clay picture with no remainder. Man’s will is a thing. Therefore man’s will is absolutely and completely controlled by God. That is not an extra claim. It is the major premise applied to a particular case. No new information is added. No category is violated. The law of identity holds. Controlled is controlled. A is A.
The post wants to say something like: “Yes, God controls the will, but within the infinite number of good options the saint (or Adam) still gets a little room to choose, that is separate from God directly and absolutely controlling the choice.” That is the category error. Either that “little freedom” is itself controlled by God, or it is not.
If it is controlled by God, then you have not said anything different from “all things are things absolutely and completely controlled by God.” You have only restated the major premise in a misleading way that pretends to leave a gap. It is like saying, “I fully control every move of the chess pieces, but the knight still has a little freedom to choose which good square it lands on.” No. If I control every move, the knight’s “choice” is already included. My hand is on the knight. Every possible “good” square the knight could land on is already selected by the pressure of my fingers. The knight isn’t freestyling in a residual zone of un-caused bounce. It’s my script. Pretending otherwise is just confusing people, the same silly maneuver Cheung mocks with the door.
If it is not controlled by God, then you have denied the major premise. You have said some things are not things absolutely controlled by God. That is some sovereignty and some not sovereignty. Some sovereignty is not all sovereignty. You cannot keep the name “absolute” while carving out an exception. That violates the law of identity. A thing cannot both be fully determined by God and not fully determined by God at the same time in the same sense.
As Vincent Cheung wrote in “Two Silly Things”:
“If I assert that I have power over my door, you could think you are very clever and point out that my closing the door is compatible with the door closing. Of course! And the door is not coerced! But this does not grant any freedom to the door, and the door does not close by its own will and power. The statement fails to make any point other than to reaffirm that I have power over the door.”
“The biblical doctrine is much simpler: God is sovereign, and man is not free. Divine sovereignty is incompatible with man’s freedom.”
That is the point. Adding “but he still has a little freedom among the good choices” is the same silly maneuver. It either reaffirms the premise while pretending not to, or it denies the premise while pretending not to. Either way it is a category error. The specific information (“man’s will is controlled”) is already contained in the major premise. You do not get to add a leftover independent “arbiter” without changing what the major premise means.
Picture it this way. A chef says, “I completely control every ingredient and every step of this pizza.” Then someone says, “Yes, but the pepperoni still has a little freedom to arrange itself among the good options.” If the chef controls every ingredient and every step, the pepperoni’s arrangement is already included. Claiming the pepperoni has bounded freedom to pick its spot is like the pepperoni forming a union and demanding residual agency from the guy who bought the meat, sliced it, and placed it. No. The curl is the chef. The spot is the chef. There is no pepperoni committee. Calling the leftover wiggle “bounded freedom” does not create a new category of uncaused agency. It just confuses the categories. The pizza is either fully under the chef’s control or it is not. There is no third option where the pepperoni is both fully controlled and independently choosing. 2+2=4 is either true or it is not. Jesus was born in Bethlehem is either true or it is not.
The same applies to Adam in the garden and the saints in glory. Adam’s decision was a thing. Therefore it was absolutely controlled by God. The saints’ successive delights in the infinite glory of God are things. Therefore they are absolutely controlled by God. God is not a puppeteer jerking lifeless dolls; His control is much greater than that. Part of God’s control is making man experience life from their human level, or point of view. Because God’s control is so exhaustive, man experiences this level with perfect and great liveliness. Their experience is real from their point of view because God has the sovereign control to make them experience it that way. Demanding an independent “can-do-otherwise” among goods is demanding that they stop being fully dependent creatures. That is dualism; but the Bible says there is none beside God.
Vincent hammered this in The Author of Sin and elsewhere that once you affirm exhaustive divine causation, any leftover “freedom” relative to God is nonsense. I have written the same in my Systematic Theology and in posts on sovereignty and category errors: responsibility comes from being under the Potter’s authority, not from having a gap in His control. The post’s attempt to keep a little independent picking among goods is the same old dualism. It commits the category error it thinks it is diagnosing.
Vincent first brought to my attention that category errors are likely the #1 mistake he finds in writing, particularly in non-Christians, but Christians still struggle with this. After studying logic myself, I agree. In this instance the faithless theologian recognizes the importance of spotting category errors, and not surprisingly, they cannot do it correctly even when they try to focus on the error directly.
The way to avoid category errors is to affirm the major premise in all its applications of knowledge.
This also shows us again that the common experience with educated people and well-read people is that they are better at deceiving themselves. They have been taught complicated ways to deceive themselves. Yet, they cannot even apply the law of identity and basic categories. There is a reason why Paul had to explain theology in basic teaching that says, grace is grace and law is the law, and grace isn’t the law, and because you hope for what you cannot see, why do you hope for what you see? Because educated people used complexity to deceive themselves, they expect you to defeat them in complexity. But they are offended when you point out that grace is grace and grace isn’t law. They are offended when you only use the law of contradiction and identity to show how dumb their argument is.
Existence Exists!!
‘MetaChristianity’ at X, responded with the following against the doctrine that “All things are things directly and absolutely controlled by God,” and for the conclusion to be valid and to avoid category errors, the application must affirm the major premise in particulars without adding new manufactured information.
They said, if that is true then:
“The Fall is Eden’s primary decree.
Evil is found to be necessary.
Christ is Beholden to Adam’s fall, and evil.
Evil is necessary to achieve good.”
Christ Is the Goal, Not a Reaction:
The graphic is titled “Christ Isn’t Plan-B” sets two columns against each other. One column is labeled as making the Fall the primary decree, with evil necessary and Christ somehow beholden to Adam’s choices and to evil. The other column claims that the only plan is Christ, that Christ is not beholden to evil or to Adam, and that God is sufficient. The contrast is presented as if the first view turns Christ into a reaction and the second view keeps Him primary. That is itself the category error.
The chart flips the categories. It treats the Fall as if it were the original starting point, then asks whether Christ is somehow stuck behind it. That’s the category error. Once you keep the categories basic and in order, the chart’s claims don’t hold.
Scripture begins with a simple statement: God “works all things according to the counsel of His will” (Ephesians 1:11). Either God determines every event, every inclination, and every choice, or something remains outside His determination. There is no stable middle position that still lets God be God. Relative to other creatures there may be descriptions of non-coercion. Relative to God—the only relevant reference point—there is none. Adam’s act in Eden, every subsequent human decision, and every angelic choice are divine effects. The graphic’s language of Christ being “beholden” assumes the opposite starting point. It treats creaturely acts as if they can stand in front of the divine purpose and constrain it. That is the reverse of the biblical order. Creaturely acts are the effects, not the cause of the purpose.
Logical order, not chronological order.
The first thing in the order of intention is the end goal: a glorified people made one body with Christ in heaven, to the glory of the Father. That is the original purpose. Everything else is arranged backward from that. Eden, the Fall, the cross, the resurrection, the ongoing sanctification—all of it is means to that end. The Fall is not “Eden’s Primary Decree.” It is a step God chose on the way to the decree that comes first in intention: the elect glorified with the Son.
Also, what does “primary” even mean? In any purpose-oriented mind the end comes first in conception, and the means are chosen afterward to reach that end. The logical order of God’s purpose begins with the goal: the elect glorified together with Christ in heaven, for the praise of the glory of God (Ephesians 1:4–12; Isaiah 43:7; Revelation 4:11). To reach that end God decrees the division into elect and reprobate, the fall of humanity, and the creation of humanity.
Historical execution runs in the opposite direction; logical intention runs from the goal backward. This is how any coherent purpose works. As Vincent reminds us in Theology 2023 (as I loosely paraphrase): A man who intends to arrive at the office first conceives the destination, then decides the route, then the intermediate steps. The first physical action is not the first choice; the destination is. You don’t start with “the alarm clock rings” and call that the primary purpose of your day. The office is primary. The Fall is the alarm clock, not the office.
“Evil is necessary” is an empty phrase.
If God determines everything, then whatever He does is necessary in the trivial sense that He did it. At that point the word “necessary” no longer distinguishes anything. It is like saying “existence exists.”
(I want my readers to see the tactic of the faithless. They act like they are saying something important. But all they are doing is saying something as trivial as existence exists, and then they want you to waste your time to address this point as if it’s important or relevant. They say nothing and want you to focus your time on nothing. Mock it and dismiss it. Saying “evil is necessary” after affirming God does all things is as deep as saying “the pizza is a pizza” after the chef already made it. Point at the rock and demand a treatise on why the rock is a rock. Then walk away.)
“Necessary” without a fixed reference point means nothing. Since God determines all things, every event He brings about can be called necessary relative to His will. The word then collapses into “whatever God has decided.” It no longer distinguishes anything. As Vincent Cheung points out in the Absurd Idea of Need, a similar issue happens. The same problem appears with the ordinary idea of “need.” Need has no independent meaning. You can always need less. A Christian doesn’t even need food or clothing, because if they die, they go to heaven; thus, based on need, they don’t even need to breathe. A person may say he needs bread, but if he wants a steak he needs the steak. If he is willing to survive on less, or even not to survive, the supposed need evaporates. Need is always relative to a want, desire or a purpose. What a person needs is simply what he wants.
The same holds for God. What is necessary is what God wants. What God wants is the original goal: the elect and the Son glorified together in heaven. God does not stand under an external necessity that forces Him to include evil. He freely decides the means that will accomplish the end He has set. Evil is therefore not an independent necessity; it is a means included because it serves the purpose. Romans 9:22–23 states one of those purposes plainly: God prepared vessels of wrath in order to make the riches of His glory known to the vessels of mercy. The elect receive a knowledge of God’s wrath, power, and justice that they would never have experienced in themselves, since they are saved from that wrath. That is not evil commanding the plan. That is the plan using evil as context. Evil is the training dummy, not the coach.
Christ is not beholden to Adam or to evil.
The reverse is true. Adam’s choice is determined by God. “The king’s heart is in the hand of the Lord; He turns it wherever He wishes” (Proverbs 21:1). “Who has spoken and it came to pass, unless the Lord has commanded it?” (Lamentations 3:37). God works in His people both to will and to do of His good pleasure (Philippians 2:13). Because the original intention was the glorification of the church in Christ, every step—including Adam’s act—is oriented toward that intention. Adam does not set the agenda. God sets the agenda and then causes Adam to perform the act that advances it.
Evil is likewise subservient. It does not stand over the purpose; the purpose stands over it. Evil supplies the low-level contrast and context in which the elect are trained, matured, and brought to glory. It is the foil that makes the display of mercy, patience, and redeeming power intelligible. The reprobate are “prepared for destruction” so that the elect may see what they have been delivered from and may know the God who delivers them (Romans 9:22–23). In that sense evil functions as training material under the larger design, not as the design itself. Christ is not reactive to it. The entire arrangement, including the presence of evil, exists so that the Son and the elect may be glorified together.
In my book Systematic Theology, I refer to this as farming fodder in a game for experience and levels. You level up on the fodder. The context, the conflict, the training—all of it exists so the elect become mature, active, joyful sons in the image of the One who determines. Joshua and Caleb called the inhabitants of the land as “food.” The evil people of Canaan were food for Israel to eat and level up on, as they destroyed them. This is similar here. Evil does not set the terms. It is the food for the elect to get fed, gain levels and mature. The purpose sets the terms. Joshua and Caleb weren’t being poetic. The Canaanites were literal food. XP snacks. God designed the dungeon so the elect could grind levels on wrath-vessels and come out knowing mercy from the inside. You don’t ask the goblin if it freely chose to be the XP farm. The designer placed it there. The elect level up. Glory to the Player. Evil is the tutorial dungeon that levels the saints into mature, joyful sons who know the difference between wrath and mercy.
God is sufficient, and the means are His too.
Once an end is fixed, the means chosen to reach it become necessary relative to that end. A builder who decides to construct a house will regard certain steps as necessary to finish the house. Those steps are not necessary in the abstract; they are necessary because he wants the house. God is not under any external compulsion. He is sufficient. He needs nothing outside Himself. He wants the display of His glory in the union of the elect with Christ. Having set that want, He has also set the subsequent steps that will realize it. Those steps include the Fall and the presence of evil. They are necessary only in the limited sense that they are the means He selected for the end He desired. They are not an independent requirement that binds Him.
God does not need the Fall the way a human needs a tool he can’t control. He wants the end, and He determines every step that gets there. That is sufficiency, not dependence. He is not beholden to His own means any more than the chef is beholden to the pepperoni he already controlled into place.
Simple statements, no sophistry:
• Either God determines all things (including Adam’s choice and the existence of evil) or He does not.
• The first thing in the order of purpose is the glorified elect with Christ.
• What is “necessary” in any meaningful sense is what God wants for that purpose.
• Therefore Adam and evil are beholden to the purpose; the purpose is not beholden to them.
• Evil serves as the determined context in which the elect are trained. It is not the primary decree.
Existence exists. Control is control. The elect in Christ are Plan A. Everything else is the supporting cast. Absolute sovereignty has no leftovers. The category holds.
